A white-winged scoter decoy carved from Maine white cedar and finished in oils

Decoy carving is an art form that has its roots in the early history of America. Native Americans would form decoys from cattails, bullrushes, and reeds. The naturally buoyant properties of these plants allowed the decoys to float easily in areas where ducks and geese would forage or roost. Hidden in nearby tules, hunters would wait patiently to arrow, snare, or net the unsuspecting waterfowl. Modern decoys are crafted from cork or wood – namely cedar, white or sugar pine, basswood, and tupelo. Many of my own decoys are carved from white cedar. A piece of clear, kiln dried Maine white cedar makes a wonderful decoy and is a joy to carve.
In the market gunning period from 1900 until approximately 1920, market hunters would deploy several hundred cork or wood decoys to lure whole flocks of waterfowl within gun range. It was not uncommon for a hunter to kill 200 ducks in one day, which would then be sold to high-end restaurants in New York and Chicago. The decoys of this time were often crudely made, and were constructed from whatever was readily available. Cedar and pine telephone poles were easy to come by, as were old crab and lobster buoys. Some decoys were made from used scallop bags that were stuffed with sawdust and then painted to make them water tight. These decoys may not have been the prettiest to behold, but they were effective and they did serve a purpose.
It wasn’t until the twilight years of the market gunning era that decoys began to take on more of an artistic look and feel. Carvers like Elmer Crowell and Charles “Shang” Wheeler started producing decoys that had greater detail. Their birds had turned or tucked heads, intricate feather detailing, and the paint was often meticulous. In recent years, some of Crowell’s decoys have fetched upwards of $1 million at auction. Not bad for a guy who carved many of his decoys in a small wooden shed in Harwich, MA. A number of contemporary decoy carvers draw their inspiration from these early craftsmen. Their style and method for producing a finished decoy are influenced by the original designs of Crowell, Shang Wheeler, Albert Laing, and many others.
A drake eider carved by Capt. Gerald Smith of Marblehead, MA

A drake eider carved by Capt. Gerald Smith of Marblehead, MA

Some current decoy carvers include Keith Mueller, Pat Godin, Tom Christie, and Jim Schmiedlin. Though the tools of today may be more advanced, the overall objective of these modern carvers is the same as it was 80-90 years ago – to create something lifelike from an inanimate chunk of wood.  In the pages that follow, we will take a deeper look at the tools and methods that are employed to produce a functional gunning decoy. I hope to cover all of the bases, from laying out a pattern and bandsawing the initial shape of a decoy, to the final painting and finish.  

An Elmer Crowell-style merganser decoy carved and painted by Keith Mueller

An Elmer Crowell-style merganser decoy carved and painted by Keith Mueller

4 Responses to Decoys

  1. Hi Steve,
    Its been quite a while since we have seen each other or corasponded.Nice site you have & right up.
    Be in touch . Thanks PAUL

  2. garden shed says:

    I was recommended this blog through my cousin. I am no longer certain whether this submit is written by him as no one else know such specific about my difficulty. You are wonderful! Thanks!

    • Hi Garden Shed,

      I’ve neglected this blog for a bit. Been busy with work, new house, kids, dog training, carving, etc., etc., etc. What questions do you have? Happy to help and answer your questions.

      Nate Grace

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s